No Choice but To Talk To Taliban On Afghan Deportations, Says EU

Magnus Brunner, the European Union’s Commissioner for Internal Affairs and Migration, has defended the controversial plan to invite Taliban representatives to Brussels.

Magnus Brunner, the European Union’s Commissioner for Internal Affairs and Migration, has defended the controversial plan to invite Taliban representatives to Brussels.
He said the EU has no choice but to talk to the Taliban if it wants to return rejected Afghan asylum seekers to Afghanistan.
The remarks come amid a wave of criticism across Europe over the invitation, with some critics arguing that it represents a retreat from the EU’s core values and principles.
Brunner stressed that contacts with the Taliban are purely technical and operational and do not in any way amount to recognition of the group’s government.
“It’s no option not to talk to these people in order to improve the situation,” he said. “At least to improve the situation for Europeans, but also for asylum applicants and asylum-seekers.”
According to reports, around 20 of the EU’s 27 member states have signed a joint letter calling for practical mechanisms to deport Afghan nationals who do not qualify for residency, particularly those with criminal records or convictions for serious offences.
In recent years, the EU has shifted its migration policy focus from preventing arrivals to accelerating the return of rejected asylum seekers.
Human Rights Criticism
Human rights organisations and UN experts have strongly criticised the policy. They argue that forcibly returning asylum seekers to Taliban-ruled Afghanistan, amid a severe humanitarian crisis, widespread poverty and sweeping restrictions on women and girls, is both unlawful and unethical.
The European Union says Afghan nationals lodged nearly one million asylum applications in member states between 2013 and 2024, with roughly half of them being approved.
Meanwhile, Germany has also begun deporting some Afghan nationals with criminal convictions since 2024.