The Taliban said on 1 August that seven people had been killed in Kabul’s eighth police district, describing them as “armed robbers”.
Bennett wrote on X on Monday that reports of people being killed during Taliban security operations in Kabul were concerning.
He referred to the shooting of four people on Monday and the killing of seven others in recent days in the eighth police district, saying the incidents should be investigated urgently and impartially.
He added that the use of lethal force must comply with international human rights law and the principles of necessity and proportionality.
Taliban police said on Monday, 10 August, that four people had been killed in Kabul’s 18th police district.
Khalid Zadran, spokesman for the Taliban police command in Kabul, said the men were “armed” and had entered a house to steal.
According to him, Taliban forces clashed with the men after arriving at the scene.
The Taliban said all four were killed and that two pistols were recovered from them.
Nine days earlier, Taliban forces killed seven other people in the Stanikzai Blocks area of Kabul’s eighth police district.
Zadran said those men were also “armed robbers” and had opened fire on Taliban forces first.
He said one Taliban member was wounded in the clash and that a vehicle and several weapons were seized.
Afghanistan International spoke to relatives of some of those killed. They rejected the Taliban’s account and said their relatives had been shot dead without trial.
According to information received by Afghanistan International, some of those killed were Hazara.
Families Initially Unaware of Their Relatives’ Fate
An informed source told Afghanistan International that the families of the seven people killed on 1 August initially had no information about their relatives’ fate.
According to the source, after the men disappeared, their families separately approached Taliban police stations seeking information.
Taliban police officials initially said they knew nothing about them.
The families were later told to go to the eighth police district because seven people accused of robbery had been killed there.
They later identified their relatives after seeing photographs of the bodies at the forensic medicine department.
The bodies were subsequently handed over to their families.
A relative of one of those killed told Afghanistan International that his family was financially well-off.
In his view, the young man had no reason to resort to theft.
Reactions to the Killings of People Accused of Robbery
The killings have also prompted reactions on social media.
Some users supported the Taliban, while others questioned why the men were not arrested and put on trial.
Referring to the Taliban’s claim that two pistols had been recovered from the four men killed, one user wrote that the main issue was that they had been summarily executed.
The user alleged that they had been shot after being detained.
He added that people should not encourage rulers to kill or deprive others of their rights, warning that anyone could face the same fate in the future.
Following the killing of the seven men in the eighth police district, Fazl Ahmad Manawi, justice minister in Afghanistan’s former regime, also described the incident as a summary execution.
Manawi said that in Islamic jurisprudence and law, the presumption of innocence is a fundamental principle, and no one is considered guilty merely on the basis of an accusation.
He called for an independent investigation into the incident.
This is not the first time the Taliban’s account of people it described as “armed robbers” being killed has been disputed by other sources.
In February 2025, the Taliban described three people killed in Nimroz as “armed robbers”, but local sources said they were not thieves.
On 4 June this year, the Taliban also accused two people killed in Herat of robbery.
An armed group opposed to the Taliban later said the two were its members and had been killed during an attack on a Taliban checkpoint.
UNAMA: Complaints Against Taliban Forces Go Unanswered
UNAMA issued a report on Monday, 10 August, on accountability for Taliban security forces and officials in response to public complaints.
The mission said Taliban security agencies had provided no statistics on the number of complaints about misconduct by their forces or the outcomes of investigations into those complaints.
UNAMA also said it had documented numerous cases in which complaints remained unresolved.
According to the mission, some people refrain from filing complaints against Taliban forces because they fear retaliation and lack confidence in the existing complaint mechanisms.
UNAMA also reported cases in which no investigation or arrest followed serious allegations of human rights violations.
The mission expressed concern as well about some Taliban military courts refusing to accept complaints filed by members of the public against Taliban forces.