One opposition figure told Afghanistan International that the Taliban leader was deeply concerned about the group’s situation and that the struggle against the Taliban had only just begun.
Opposition figures said growing public discontent, mounting pressure and the strengthening of resistance groups had alarmed Akhundzada. They argued that his offer of participation was not about sharing power but about appointing opponents as officials within the Taliban administration.
Yasin Zia, leader of the Afghanistan Freedom Front (AFF), told Afghanistan International that Akhundzada’s remarks were a result of his group’s armed resistance against the Taliban.
Zia said opposition figures were not seeking government posts, having already served in various positions under the former government. He said the Taliban leader must agree to the formation of a government in which sovereignty rests with the people and all citizens enjoy equal rights.
‘I Do Not Take Akhundzada’s Invitation Seriously’
Mohammad Mohaqiq, leader of the People’s Islamic Unity Party of Afghanistan, told Afghanistan International that he did not take the Taliban leader’s remarks seriously.
Asked what Akhundzada’s invitation to opponents after five years signified, Mohaqiq said: “I do not know the reason behind it, but I do not take it seriously.”
Fazl Ahmad Manawi, a former justice minister and member of the National Resistance Front (NRF), also told Afghanistan International that Akhundzada was not seeking political partnership with his opponents.
“He does not want partners; he wants government functionaries,” Manawi said.
According to Manawi, the Taliban are facing mounting internal pressure because of their monopolisation of power.
Sharing Government Posts Will Not Satisfy The Public
Meanwhile, Shah Mahmood Miakhel, a former acting defence minister, said government positions were the right of the people rather than favours granted by those in power.
In a post on X, Miakhel dismissed Akhundzada’s remarks as “empty talk”, saying government positions were not gifts for the Taliban to distribute as they pleased. He argued that the people, rather than a small group or a dictator, were the rightful owners of the state and its political system.
Miakhel said that as long as Afghanistan lacked a constitution, public participation in governance could not be secured simply by distributing government posts, as it was the constitution that determined how citizens participated in the political system.
He added that the Taliban appeared to believe that most Afghans opposed the group’s approach to governance and its ideology because they wanted government positions, and that their opposition would end once they were given such posts.
Miakhel rejected this interpretation, saying Afghans wanted their rights guaranteed within a constitutional framework.
He called on the Taliban to pave the way for the establishment of a legitimate, democratic and law-based political system through intra-Afghan dialogue.
An Invitation To Submission And Unquestioning Obedience
Daoud Naji, head of the political office of the Afghanistan Freedom Front, told Afghanistan International that Akhundzada’s speech was not an invitation to political participation but a call for opponents to accept a subordinate role within the Taliban’s governing structure.
“If we examine the speech as a whole, it was an invitation to become either subjects or government functionaries,” Naji said.
He added that public opinion and the aspirations of the Afghan people had no place in the Taliban’s political system.
According to Naji, Akhundzada’s concerns about growing public discontent, the strengthening of resistance groups and internal divisions within the Taliban were evident throughout his speech.
“The Taliban are worried — worried about public discontent, worried about the strengthening of resistance fronts and worried about their own internal divisions. His anxiety was apparent throughout the speech, but the mullah’s solution to these concerns was unquestioning obedience,” he said.
Taliban Concerns Over Domestic And External Crises
Hafiz Mansour, a member of the National Resistance Front led by Ahmad Massoud, also believes that Akhundzada’s remarks stemmed from concerns about the Taliban’s current predicament.
Referring to regional developments, Mansour said the regional consensus in support of the Taliban had fractured, the group’s relations with Pakistan had deteriorated into a crisis, and Islamabad had begun providing military and political support to Taliban opponents.
He described these developments as signs of mounting pressure on the Taliban, saying Akhundzada had become increasingly concerned about the growing threats facing his administration.
Mansour also argued that, in terms of their relations with regional and international powers, Taliban opposition groups now found themselves in a position similar to that occupied by the Taliban several years before their return to power.
Given these circumstances, he said, political groups opposed to the Taliban had no reason to accept subordinate positions within Akhundzada’s administration.
Akhundzada’s Unprecedented Offer To Opponents
On Tuesday, 17 November, the Taliban leader publicly raised the possibility of granting government positions to opponents of the group for the first time. He said the Taliban were prepared to award government posts on the basis of competence and merit.
Addressing his opponents, Akhundzada said he did not regard them as his enemies, claiming that his only enemies were “disbelievers”.
He urged Taliban opponents to return to Afghanistan and live in their own country.
“Do you want a role in government? Do you want government posts? Whatever you want, these will be granted on the basis of competence and ability. If you are qualified, we will give them to you. If someone else is qualified, we will give them to that person,” he said.
Over the past five years, Taliban officials have rejected calls for negotiations with their opponents and the formation of an inclusive government. Instead, they have urged opposition figures to return to Afghanistan as ordinary citizens and comply with the Taliban leader’s orders.
The Taliban’s intelligence agency has also restricted the activities of former President Hamid Karzai and Abdullah Abdullah, two prominent Afghan political figures based in Kabul, and continues to monitor their communications.
This is despite Karzai having repeatedly expressed support for the Taliban and Abdullah having refrained from making public statements on political matters.