Rule By Fear & Force Is Not Legitimate Governance, Says Haqqani

Ministry spokesperson Sonja Kock said some Afghan refugees will soon be informed that there is no longer any political justification for accepting them.

German media reported that, under the ministry’s new decision, the resettlement process for at least 640 Afghan refugees in Pakistan will be cancelled.

Around 1,800 Afghan refugees who fled to Pakistan after the Taliban takeover and applied for resettlement in Germany because they feared persecution remain in the country. The German government had previously promised to accept them.

According to Deutsche Welle, at least 130 Afghan refugees in Pakistan have already received letters informing them that their acceptance into Germany has been revoked. The letters were sent by GIZ, Germany’s development agency.

The letter states: “After further detailed examination, it has been decided that there are no grounds for granting admission to Germany under Section 22 of the Residence Act.” The notice does not explain why the earlier pledge of acceptance was withdrawn.

Reports say many of those affected previously worked as local staff on German-funded projects before the collapse of the former Afghan government and the Taliban’s return to power.

The Interior Ministry spokesperson said that among the remaining 220 former local employees, 90 are still eligible to apply for admission.

Germany’s previous government, a coalition of Social Democrats, Greens and Liberals, had pledged to admit women’s rights activists, lawyers, journalists and other Afghan dissidents through the so-called “human rights list” and “bridge list.”

That government relocated several Afghan women’s rights activists, lawyers, journalists and political opponents of the Taliban under special programmes. However, the current government under Chancellor Friedrich Merz has said it intends to restrict refugee resettlement programmes as much as possible.

According to official figures, from the Taliban takeover until April 2025, Germany admitted about 4,000 former Afghan local employees and nearly 15,000 of their family members.

In an interview with Afghanistan International, Atmar referred to the recent “unity of voice” among Afghan political movements, saying all sides have jointly declared that their preference is not war but a political settlement achieved through negotiation and dialogue.

He said the Taliban must respond positively to this demand but added: “I am not sure the Taliban will do so.”

Atmar warned that if the Taliban refuse to engage in talks, they will push Afghanistan into a “major disaster” and create opportunities for the country’s enemies.

He said the international community should not support war and bloodshed in Afghanistan, but instead back a political solution and help facilitate intra-Afghan dialogue.

Atmar said Afghanistan is no longer a priority for the international community, but stressed that the world must still honour its commitments to the country.

He added that the Taliban have failed to uphold their obligations under the Doha Agreement, saying such behaviour contradicts Islamic teachings.

In another part of the interview, Atmar addressed rising tensions between the Taliban and Pakistan, describing them as a “real crisis” and saying: “These tensions will not be resolved by issuing fatwas.”

Referring to the previous Afghan government’s efforts to reach a political settlement with Pakistan, Atmar said: “As part of those efforts, I travelled to Pakistan ten times to secure Mullah Baradar’s release so that negotiations could move forward.” He added that he does not trust Pakistan.

Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar is one of the founders of the Taliban and a close associate of the group’s founder, Mullah Omar. He was arrested by Pakistan’s intelligence service in 2010 and held until 2018. Baradar was released following US efforts, particularly by Zalmay Khalilzad, the former US special representative for Afghanistan, and later became head of the Taliban’s political office in Qatar.

Baradar was a signatory to the Doha peace agreement between the Taliban and the United States. He now serves as the Taliban administration’s deputy prime minister for economic affairs and is regarded as one of the most influential figures in Kabul’s current leadership.

Speaking at the third Madrid meeting on the situation of women in Afghanistan, Bennett warned against normalising relations with the Taliban and said human rights conditions in the country have continued to deteriorate.

He said the Taliban have dismantled legal and judicial structures as well as institutions that supported women, leaving women particularly vulnerable to the consequences of these policies.

The UN rapporteur urged countries to make any engagement with the Taliban conditional on respect for human rights, especially the rights of women.

Bennett said the vision for Afghanistan should not be abandoned and described the current situation as a test for the international community. He warned that normalising relations with the Taliban would be both morally and strategically wrong and stressed that the group must be held accountable.

He emphasised that clear conditions must be set for any interaction with the Taliban and that no engagement should proceed unless those requirements are met. He called on governments to uphold their international commitments and to support the rights of Afghan women and citizens.

Reiterating the need for accountability, Bennett said the Taliban have targeted women, ethnic minorities, human rights defenders and former government employees.

Speaking at a gathering of Afghan activists in Madrid, Albares said Spain remains firmly committed to the rights of Afghan women and that genuine peace cannot be achieved without their participation.

The third special conference on Afghan women, titled “Hear Us,” opened on Friday in Madrid. Richard Bennett, the UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Afghanistan, along with several human rights activists, is among the speakers.

In his opening remarks, Albares said any future based on progress requires the inclusion of women and reaffirmed Madrid’s support for the rights of Afghan women.

He described the past four years in Afghanistan as devastating for women and warned that failure in their struggle would weaken equality not only in Afghanistan but beyond its borders.

Albares also said the Taliban’s actions in Afghanistan would be reviewed and that the group must be held accountable.

The conference’s first session was held on Thursday. Two previous rounds of the meeting were organised in Spain and Albania, focusing on supporting the struggle of Afghan women.

Last year, on December 11, he was killed by an ISIS suicide bomber inside his ministry, yet the ambiguous aspects of that incident remain unclear even after one year.

August 2007 was a defining moment for Khalil-ur Rahman Haqqani, as he was released as part of a major hostage-taking and prisoner-exchange deal orchestrated by Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP). Following his release, he returned to the battlefield.

After negotiations failed between a 21-member jirga of the Mehsud tribe, led by former Pakistani parliamentarian Maulana Merajuddin Mehsud, and the TTP regarding the exchange of captured soldiers and detainees, TTP leader Baitullah Mehsud killed three captured Pakistani soldiers when the Afghan and Pakistani Taliban were not released. Their bodies were dumped on the Wana–Jandola road. Mehsud warned: “If you do not release the prisoners, we will give you such gifts every day.”

One of the TTP’s key demands was the release of Khalil-ur Rahman Haqqani and other members of the Haqqani Network.

After the killing of the soldiers, the Pakistani government agreed to negotiations. Talks between the Pakistan army and the TTP were held in Dila, South Waziristan, led by Mawlawi Muawiya Wazirgi, the TTP’s head of economic affairs. Under the deal, the army released several tribal elders from Waziristan, along with 43 Taliban leaders, including Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani, Nasiruddin Haqqani, Amir Khan Haqqani, two brothers of Akhtar Mohammad Osmani, and Malai Khan Zadran.

The dramatic capture of 350 Pakistani soldiers by 20 Taliban fighters in South Waziristan, and the subsequent release of a large group of Haqqani Network members in exchange, strengthened public suspicions that the entire episode was a jointly planned operation to secure the release of senior Haqqani leaders. At the time, US forces posed a significant threat of capturing Haqqani Network members and transferring them to Bagram or Guantanamo prisons.

Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani, who was killed last year on December 11 by an ISIS suicide bomber inside the Taliban’s Ministry of Refugees and Repatriation, had been arrested by Pakistani forces in 2003 and imprisoned. From guesthouses linked to the Haqqani Network in Peshawar including Board, University Town, Hayatabad, Kohat Road and Chamakani he commanded fronts against Afghan and US forces in Afghanistan. Known as “Haji Lala,” he led the Peshawar-based wing of the Haqqani Network. Since the days of the Afghan jihad, he maintained close ties with Pakistan’s intelligence services as well as with the country’s political, religious and militant groups.

Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani was the brother of the Haqqani Network’s founder, Mawlawi Jalaluddin Haqqani, and the uncle of Sirajuddin Haqqani, the Taliban’s current interior minister. He was considered one of the most influential members of the network, often handling tribal mediation and coordination among communities.

He also played a decisive role in expanding the Haqqani Network’s influence in Afghanistan.

In February 2011, the US Treasury Department added his name to its sanctions list and announced a $5 million bounty on him.

On February 9 the same year, the United Nations, under Paragraph 2 of Resolution 1904 (2009), listed Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani for maintaining close ties with al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden. He was accused of playing a key role in transferring the families and members of al-Qaeda and other foreign militants from Shahi Kot, Paktia, Paktika and Khost provinces into Waziristan.

Haqqani’s Position Within the Taliban Structure

Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani was considered one of the most active ministers during the Taliban’s second rule, serving as minister of refugees and repatriation. The ministry’s most important responsibility was overseeing the return of millions of Afghan refugees who, after decades of war, were facing mass expulsions from Iran and Pakistan. According to Taliban sources, during his tenure he managed the forced deportation and return of nearly 1.5 million Afghan refugees, a mission the Taliban viewed as a major political achievement.

Alongside his cabinet role, the senior Haqqani played a key part in expanding the influence of the Haqqani Network. He was regarded as Sirajuddin Haqqani’s “right hand” because of his strong connections with tribal elders, tribal structures and hard-line factions within the Taliban. Through jirgas and mediation efforts in Khost, Paktia and Paktika, he helped build an environment of support for the Taliban, a contribution seen as vital to consolidating the group’s authority.

During his tenure, delegations of tribal elders from Afghanistan’s southern provinces were sent to northern regions to strengthen intertribal relations and to fill the ideological gap in Taliban governance by reinforcing the Haqqani Network’s influence through tribal legitimacy.

Haji E’tibar, a 71-year-old who fought alongside Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani against the government during the rule of President Mohammad Najibullah, told Afghanistan International–Pashto that Khalil Haqqani played a key role in the fall of Khost province during the Soviet-backed Najibullah regime in the late 1980s. He was also a close aide to Mawlawi Jalaluddin Haqqani, and when the Haqqani Network captured numerous tanks during the war, it was under Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani’s leadership that an armoured battalion was formed.

Expanding the Haqqani Network’s influence, maintaining relations with the Taliban’s central leadership and generating legitimacy for the Taliban through tribal structures were among the roles in which Khalil Haqqani was deeply involved.

A member of the Taliban-controlled Centre for Regional Studies, speaking on condition of anonymity, told Afghanistan International–Pashto that after the fall of the Taliban’s first regime in the 1990s, Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani worked to maintain and expand the Haqqani Network’s bases in North Waziristan. He managed the transfer and accommodation of foreign fighters, an effort described as crucial for al-Qaida and other global jihadist networks.

The source said: “As I recall, during the Taliban’s first rule, Khalil Haqqani had very close relations with Osama bin Laden, al-Hassami and several other al-Qaida members. He was one of their most trusted individuals.”

Securing supply routes for the Haqqani Network, procuring weapons and equipment, and managing financial resources were areas in which Khalil Haqqani played a decisive role. His activities were heavily focused in Pakistan’s urban areas, where he maintained an extensive network of contacts and operations.

The research centre member added: “His relationships with tribes in Pakistan dated back to the jihad era. He had strong ties with Sunni tribes in Kurram Agency, while at the same time maintaining cooperative relations with Pakistani state institutions. The Kurram Agreement, which aimed to end sectarian conflict, secured strategic locations for the Haqqani Network. These achievements were the direct result of Khalil Haqqani’s mediation and influence.”

The Kurram Agreement and Sectarian Conflicts

Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani and Ibrahim Haqqani played a decisive role in a 2008 agreement aimed at easing sectarian tensions in Kurram district of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Under the agreement, sectarian clashes subsided temporarily, allowing the Haqqani Network to establish itself in several strategic areas of Kurram.

According to a report by Afghanistan International–Pashto, the Pakistani military, together with Ibrahim Haqqani and Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani, played a significant role in brokering the agreement and expanding their influence among the local population. Shiite and Sunni communities deposited 40 million Pakistani rupees as surety and accepted several additional conditions and restrictions.

The Haqqanis persuaded Sunni tribes to withdraw from the conflict and, in return, gained access to supply routes from Shiite-majority areas into Afghanistan.

In the first week of December 2010, another three-day jirga was held involving Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani, several Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan commanders, tribal elders and local Pakistani officials. Haqqani again played a decisive role in the gathering.

Based on the jirga’s decisions, Afridi tribal elders from the Jamrud, Sra Kamar, Takhta Beg and Ghundi areas committed to cooperating with Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani and agreed not to obstruct supply routes.

The jirga enabled both the Haqqani Network and the Taliban to recruit young men from local religious seminaries and to use existing supply routes with greater confidence.

Another outcome of the Jamrud jirga was the recruitment of Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan fighters for the Haqqani Network’s insurgency in Afghanistan. Young men from seminaries in the Afridi, Orakzai and Tirah areas joined TTP ranks and, with the support of the Haqqani Network, carried out attacks and operations inside Afghanistan.

Leadership in Social and Political Engagements

In August 2021, as the Taliban entered Kabul and the republican government was nearing collapse, Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani was among the Taliban representatives who held direct talks with senior government officials and political leaders. According to Taliban sources, the aim was to prevent an escalation of fighting, minimise bloodshed during the fall of Kabul and facilitate a smoother transfer of power.

Reports indicate that Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani attended several meetings inside the presidential palace and held discussions with influential political figures. He conveyed messages to former President Ashraf Ghani through Hamid Karzai and Dr Abdullah Abdullah.

In his final interview, he claimed that former Balkh governor Atta Mohammad Noor had assured him of cooperation with the Taliban if they took control of Afghanistan. He also spoke respectfully of the late Ahmad Shah Massoud and expressed a willingness to meet his son, Ahmad Massoud.

Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani sought to prevent any potential armed resistance to the Taliban.

Despite these political efforts, he was critical of Taliban leader Mullah Hibatullah Akhundzada’s policies. Before his death, he openly criticised the leader’s approach during a visit to Kandahar. For this reason, some analysts view his assassination as the result of internal divisions within the Taliban.

The killing of Khalil-ur-Rahman Haqqani by ISIS during the Taliban’s second rule dealt a significant blow to the group, particularly as the Taliban publicly deny the presence of ISIS in Afghanistan and claim to have eliminated it.

A year after his death, Taliban authorities have not disclosed the findings of their investigation or identified those responsible for the attack. One of the central mysteries surrounding the incident is how the suicide bomber entered the ministry building undetected and why the security scanner was not functioning at the time. Although the Taliban officially attributed the attack to ISIS and the group claimed responsibility, the circumstances of the killing remain unclear.